CSRD, CSDDD and ESRS - key things to know in 2024.
In 2019, the European Commission launched the European Green Deal, charting a course for Europe to become the world's first climate-neutral continent. Central to this mission is fostering a green economy, directing investments towards sustainable ventures.
Legislative acts like the EU Taxonomy and the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) are pivotal in advancing this agenda. The EU Taxonomy sets clear criteria for activities to qualify as "sustainable," empowering investors to align with green goals.
Meanwhile, the CSRD replaces the Non-Financial Reporting Directive (NFRD), ushering in comprehensive Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) reporting requirements. By standardizing reporting and enhancing transparency, the CSRD propels Europe towards a more sustainable future.
1. What are CSRD and ESRS?
The CSRD, in effect since January 2023, mandates annual sustainability reporting for companies within the European Union. European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS), endorsed in July 2023, delineate specific reporting requirements, facilitating comprehensive sustainability assessment.
The CSRD requires that companies transparently report their sustainability performance annually, replacing the prior Non-Financial Reporting Directive (NFRD). This extends coverage from 12,000 to 50,000 companies, including those outside the EU.
Additionally, the European Commission approved the European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS) in July 2023. These standards specify reporting requirements for each topic, facilitating improved comparison and monitoring of sustainability performance across companies.
2. Who does the CSRD apply to?
Many companies face uncertainty regarding CSRD compliance timelines, risking reputational damage and sanctions for non-compliance. Here's a simplified timeline:
By 2025: Companies under NFRD regulations report on 2024 sustainability performance if meeting at least two of the following criteria:
> 500 employees
> 40 million Euros revenue
or > 20 million Euros total assets.
From January 2026: Large European companies report on 2025 sustainability performance if meeting at least two of the following criteria:
> 250 employees
> 50 million Euros revenue
or > 25 million Euros total assets.
From January 2027: Listed European SMEs report on 2026 sustainability performance if meeting at least two of the following criteria:
between 10 and 250 employees
€700,000-40 million Euros revenue
or €350,000-20 million Euros total assets.
From January 2029: Non-European companies with at least one subsidiary or branch in Europe and >150 million Euros turnover report for the first time, covering 2028.
3. How to comply with CSRD?
The CSRD relies on 12 European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS) to define reporting criteria. These standards, applicable across all sectors, include two overarching standards applying universally, and 10 thematic standards covering various ESG topics. Companies report only on standards deemed material or relevant based on their materiality analysis.
To comply with CSRD, companies must disclose their sustainability strategy, impact, and targets, with reports verified by a neutral third-party auditor, akin to financial reporting requirements. Companies should refer to the European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS) from EFRAG, providing guidance and required metrics.
ESRS 1 and ESRS 2 are mandatory for all CSRD companies, covering strategy overview, risks, policies, and targets, while other standards depend on materiality assessment outcomes.
4. What is a (double) materiality analysis?
A materiality analysis involves assessing which sustainability themes are pertinent to your company.
Impact materiality: Evaluates environmental or social themes influenced by the company (inside-out).
Financial materiality: Considers external sustainability-related factors impacting the company's financial status (outside-in).
The European Sustainability Reporting Standards outline criteria for determining materiality. Companies can establish a threshold for a theme to be deemed material or relevant. A theme is material if it's relevant in at least one of the two categories (impact/financial).
Footprint Intelligence offers guidance on conducting a materiality analysis, involving collaboration with your company's working group and stakeholder consultation to address diverse expectations and interests. Our newly created factsheet provides digital and media companies with comprehensive support for conducting their CSRD-compliant materiality assessment.
5. What's new in final ESRS?
Following public consultation, the European Commission adjusted the draft ESRS standards recently released. Here's a summary of the changes:
Introduction of a phased-in period of 1 or 2 years for specific reporting requirements, primarily for companies with <750 employees.
Increased flexibility in determining which themes are material for each company.
Certain reporting requirements have become voluntary.
1. The extended phase-in period applies mainly to companies with fewer than 750 employees, giving them more time to prepare.
2. Companies now have more flexibility in choosing material themes, potentially reducing costs. However, the 'General disclosures ESRS 2' standard remains mandatory for all companies. Additionally, 'Climate change ESRS E1' is subject to materiality analysis. If a company deems climate change immaterial, it must justify its decision.
3. Some reporting requirements have shifted from 'shall disclose' to 'may disclose,' particularly challenging data points such as the biodiversity transition plan and specific indicators for self-employed and temporary workers.
6. What are the steps to comply with CSRD?
Achieving CSRD compliance varies for each company, depending on factors like its business nature, phase-in schedule, and existing sustainability reporting status. Here's a summary of suggested next actions:
Define entities required for CSRD reporting, along with any needed accommodations.
Conduct a double materiality assessment to pinpoint relevant ESRS impacts, risks, and opportunities.
Address gaps between ESRS requirements and currently available information.
Collect necessary data.
Prepare for and obtain limited assurance.
7. How to optimize CSRD reporting?
On the journey to CSRD compliance, Footprint Intelligence helps companies streamline the reporting process, leveraging AI to expedite compliance. By harnessing technology, we transform this obligation into a competitive advantage, empowering companies to navigate sustainability reporting with efficiency and precision.
8. What is CSDDD?
The Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD) is a landmark EU legislation aimed at mandating companies to conduct thorough environmental and human rights due diligence across their operations, subsidiaries, and value chains. This directive ensures that businesses not only identify and address potential risks but also actively work to prevent and mitigate negative impacts on human rights and the environment.
On March 15, 2024, the European Council approved the CSDDD, followed by the EU Parliament's final approval on April 24, 2024. This milestone embeds sustainability and ethical practices into the corporate world, highlighting the EU’s commitment to responsible business conduct globally.
Scope and Coverage
• EU-Based Companies:
Applies to companies with over 500 employees and a net turnover exceeding EUR 150 million.
In addition, applies to companies with over 250 employees and a net turnover exceeding EUR 40 million, provided that 50% of their revenue comes from high-risk industries such as fashion, minerals, or agriculture.
• Non-EU Companies: Targets non-EU companies operating within the EU that meet the above-mentioned turnover thresholds, with the revenue being generated within the EU, regardless of whether they have a branch or subsidiary in the region.
Stakeholder Engagement
Companies must engage with affected stakeholders, including workers and local communities, as part of their due diligence.
Reporting and Transparency
Companies must publicly report their due diligence processes and measures taken to address adverse impacts.
Next Steps / Implementation
Depending on their size, companies will have between 3 to 5 years from the Directive entering into force to implement its requirements:
3 years (i.e., likely in 2027) for: EU companies with more than 5,000 employees and EUR 1,500 million net worldwide turnover, and non-EU companies with more than EUR 1,500 million net turnover generated in the EU.
4 years (i.e., likely in 2028) for: companies with more than 3,000 employees and EUR 900 million net worldwide turnover, and non-EU companies with more than EUR 900 million net turnover generated in the EU; and
5 years (i.e., likely in 2029) for companies with more than 1,000 employees and EUR 450 million turnover.
CSDDD & CSRD: What's the Difference?
While the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) focuses on expanding sustainability reporting, the CSDDD emphasizes the need for companies to actively engage in responsible behavior, particularly in social and environmental matters. Both aim to enhance corporate accountability and transparency, but they have different focuses and implementations:
1. Focus
CSRD: Concentrates on sustainability reporting, requiring companies to disclose their environmental, social, and governance (ESG) performance.
CSDDD: Focuses on due diligence, requiring companies to actively manage and mitigate adverse impacts on human rights and the environment.
2. Scope of Application
CSRD: Applies to a broad range of companies, including large companies and listed SMEs in the EU, and non-EU companies with significant EU operations.
CSDDD: Targets large companies, particularly those with extensive supply chains and significant impacts on human rights and the environment.
3. Requirements
CSRD: Involves annual sustainability reporting based on European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS).
CSDDD: Imposes due diligence duties, requiring risk assessments, preventive measures, and reporting on due diligence activities.
4. Reporting & Action
CSRD: Focuses on disclosure and transparency.
CSDDD: Emphasizes proactive measures to address and mitigate impacts.
5. Governance
CSRD: Enhances transparency through reporting.
CSDDD: Integrates sustainability into governance, requiring directors to consider sustainability impacts in decisions.
In summary, while CSRD enhances transparency through detailed reporting, CSDDD enforces proactive due diligence to prevent and mitigate negative impacts on human rights and the environment. Both are essential to the EU's strategy for sustainable and responsible business practices.
